I tried with another VM and got the same issue, I finally found a technet in regards to the issue because its been driving be crazy. I've been going through my Cisco router and switch like a mad man. Seems like the proxy ARP was causing this odd conflict, which makes sense because on my Cisco switch I could see in the mac address table that the request was incomplete. So in this article all you do is reset the IP and use a registry hack for it, I've used it on two of the three VMs and it has worked. I can't use it on the third because I can't take it down just yet.
